The Guardians

Members: Sign In/Sign Up Members: Sign In Not a Member?  Sign up!
Community Newsletter 

SG History 101

Sons of Song

SG History 101 - The Sons of Song

One of the most unique sounds in gospel music came around in 1957 when a trio of young gospel musicians arrived on the scene with a quality unlike any other that the industry had ever experienced.

The Sons of Song were the first male trio to achieve any manner of success in the highly competitive gospel music industry of the 1950s. The excitement the group brought to the stage was second to none. They employed unique vocal arrangements unlike any the gospel music world had heard before or since.

Calvin Newton was a seasoned veteran of several of the top gospel music quartets when he joined forces with Don Butler and Bob Robinson to form the Sons of Song. Although Newton was only 28 years of age, he had already sung in several of the finest quartets in gospel music. He spent time with the Melody Masters Quartet, Blackwood Brothers, and the Oak Ridge Quartet prior to joining the Sons of Song.

Calvin's antics both on stage and off stage proved him to be one of the most interesting characters in gospel music history. In December 1956, Calvin resigned from the Oak Ridge Quartet in particular and gospel music in general before a sold out crowd in an all-night singing in Atlanta, Ga. In an emotion-filled speech, Calvin belittled the gospel music industry for their hypocrisy. He also said he was leaving gospel music to sing in a secular nightclub and would never return to the gospel music stage.

On the other hand, Don Butler's experience singing gospel music was a bit more limited. Don had a wonderful baritone voice, and had spent a few months singing with the Revelaires Quartet. The Revelaires were a talented quartet from the Atlanta area, but they disbanded in the mid 50s leaving Don without a singing job. Although he had other job opportunities, Don missed singing gospel music. He toyed with the idea of forming a new concept in gospel music, but lacked the other personnel to make this dream a reality.

Sons of SongAlthough Bob Robinson was a very young gospel musician, but he also had sung with some of the great groups of the day including the Deep South Quartet and most recently, the LeFevres. Butler had been impressed with Bob's vocal skills as well as his unique piano technique. He suggested that they consider forming a gospel trio, but this didn't seem to interest Bob at the time. However, when Calvin Newton agreed to try out the concept, Robinson also came into the fold. Bob has been aptly described as the man "with a tear in his voice".

Trios are now quite commonplace in gospel music, but in the 50s, this was a radical change from the norm. Butler's original concept was to form a trio of gentlemen with extraordinary vocal ranges, and thus invert harmonies and switch parts to make up for the "missing" bass part. He couldn't have picked two more capable musicians to join in this concept, for Robinson and Newton both had three-octave vocal ranges as did Butler. Robinson also had a very recognizable piano technique unlike any other in gospel music. Not only did the group sound good, but they were very handsome individuals. When these gentlemen hit the stage, it was magic!

This vocal aggregation became not a typical trio, but three separate vocalists with solo capabilities par excellence. There was no "star" in the group, but rather three superb musicians with the common goal of making the overall group sound the best it could be. In doing so, the sum became much stronger than any of its individual parts.

The Sons of Song worked on their arrangements and practiced their art for many hours before they were ready to perform for the finicky gospel music audiences. They decided to display their newly formed group at an all-night singing in Birmingham, Alabama. Wally Fowler was the promoter of the event which featured the top groups of 1957. The Sons of Song were not booked for the program, but showed up dressed to the nines in matching tuxedos. Newton persuaded Fowler to put them on the program. From all accounts, they were allowed to sing through the intermission of the program, and set the audience on their ear! They left the concert with a date book full of engagements.

Sons of SongSome of the big players in the industry did their best to keep the Sons of Song at bay, but their talent, excitement, and innovative arrangements made them a force to be reckoned with in the gospel singing world. No group wanted to follow the Sons of Song on the stage for as one industry giant told me, "They left the stage so hot, the next group would just melt in their tracks trying to follow them!"

They soon became known as the first "contemporary" gospel music group. Their early recordings were produced by a young and then unknown producer: Ralph Carmichael. The Sons of Song, innovative musicians themselves, was a match made in Heaven for Mr. Carmichael. The orchestrations and arrangements they preserved on vinyl with Mr. Carmichael were light years beyond any others in gospel music at that time.

While at the top of their game musically speaking, tragedy struck the quartet in the form of a truck full of watermelons. On a rainy night summer night in Florida, the Sons of Song met on a collision course with the rear of a tractor trailer carrying watermelons. In the ensuing crunch of metal, the Sons were sent flying around their vehicle. In the aftermath, Bob Robinson was left for dead in the local hospital. Were it not for the help of their friend and future Sons of Song member, Lee Kitchens, Robinson would have likely perished.

Butler and Newton were also injured in the crash, but Robinson's injuries were the worst. It was feared that the Sons of Song would never perform again. Although they did sing again, they never regained the magic they held prior to this accident. Calvin filled several dates as the Sons of Song with Jimi Hall filling in as pianist and tenor. During Bob's recovery, Don and Calvin also called upon L.David Young to fill Bob's role in the quartet. When Bob finally returned to the group, Don decided that he would leave the group, due in part to the injuries suffered in the accident. In the aftermath, Don Butler recorded a session with the "Sentinels". . . who were actually the Statesmen Quartet in disguise. Butler worked for the Statesmen organization for several years.

Sons of SongSeveral groups were spawned after the demise of the original Sons of Song. Don Butler formed a short-lived group called the Ambassadors. The Ambassadors featured Jim Hill, Bob Robinson, Don Butler, Bill Huey, and L.David Young. During this time, Calvin reorganized the Sons of Song with Jimi Hall and Les Roberson. Roberson had previously sung with Calvin in the Oak Ridge Quartet and had more recently replaced Jake Hess as lead singer of the Statesmen Quartet. This group never had the magic of the original trio and quickly disbanded.

On July 13, 1959, Bob Robinson joined forces with Bill Morris and Al Harkins to form The Velva-Tears. This group was also quite short-lived, but it was around long enough to record a very collectable album, "His Velvet Touch". The Velva-Tears actually sounded more like the Sons of Song than did the last version of the Sons of Song.

Circumstances led Calvin Newton to visit his friend Lee Kitchens in Tampa Florida. In an effort to resurrect the magic of the Sons of Song, Calvin and Lee persuaded Bob Robinson to join them in Florida and reform the Sons. Kitchens' voice had the depth necessary to sing in the trio, but he lacked the charisma and stage presence of Don Butler. However, the Sons of Song again reorganized and became quite active on the gospel music circuit. It was this group that recorded their biggest hit, "Wasted Years".

Various indiscretions in lifestyle choices again led to the breakup of the Sons of Song. Don Butler even returned to the group for a short time, knowing that the group had never been at the top of their game after he had vacated the baritone spot. They once again gained popularity and even recorded a number of fine albums on Wally Fowler's Songs of Faith label. Personal turmoil again led to the breakup of this fine trio.

At the insistence of Lee Roy Abernathy, Calvin and Bob joined forces with Jerry Redd and Paul Downing to form another short-lived group: The All Stars. The group never made an official recording, but it had a unique sound as did all of the groups containing Newton and Robinson.

Sons of SongHoping to hold their personal demons at bay, the Sons of Song once again emerged at the request of Jake Hess. By now, Jake had become somewhat of a renegade in gospel music having formed the Imperials Quartet by recruiting some fine vocalists from other primo groups. He welcomed the Sons of Song to Nashville, and began to promote them along with the Imperials as a "team". Lee Kitchens and Bob Robinson were anxious to again be on the concert trail, but the gospel music "mafia", promoters, and fans weren't as willing to accept the prodigals back into the fold as was Mr. Hess. Again, the group disbanded and Lee, Calvin, and Bob went their separate ways.

During the ensuing years, when personal situations allowed, the Sons of Song got together periodically to sing for old timers nights. They even went into the studio to record a new album of their greatest hits with Bob, Calvin, and Lee.

Sons of SongIn the late 1980s, Charles Burke joined Calvin and Bob to again revive the Sons of Song. A new, updated recording was released and the Sons worked several major dates before Burke left the group. Roy Pauley sang with the group for a while, but again the voices of the Sons were stilled.

Bob Robinson passed away a few years ago, seemingly unnoticed by most in the gospel music industry. Calvin Newton has replaced the demons in his life with a newfound joy of singing for God. He is often seen on numerous projects, and also has an active solo ministry. He has performed Sons of Song classics in recent years with Wallace Nelms and Ken Turner.

There has never been a trio that imparted magic on the gospel music stage like the Sons of Song!

Recently, Calvin's life story was recounted in the book "Bad Boy of Gospel Music" by Russ Cheatham. Cheatham is a professor at Cumberland University, and has done a fine job with this book. Deon Unthank reviewed "Bad Boy of Gospel Music" a few months ago, so I won't go into great detail. Just let me say that I would encourage you to read this book to fill in some of the gaps this abbreviated history may have glossed over. I am greatly indebted to this book for solidifying many of these facts in this history lesson.

On a personal note, let me thank you all for your thoughts, prayers, and understanding for having missed the December installment. My thanks to Susan and Deon for their kind words about my daughter's wedding. I also thank those of you who sent your good wishes both on the web site and to us personally.

It was a beautiful service of worship, and the newlyweds are quite happy. Carol and I are relieved that this chapter in our lives has completed with a very happy ending.

About This Article - SG History 101 - The Sons of Song

Author: .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)
Written: 12/31/2003 | Category: SG History 101 Comments: 21

Ads Sponsored by

Reader Comments

I was anticipating this feature on one of the tuly accomplished and innovative groups ever to sing gospel music.../i know their recordings are hard to find, but I can personally testify that they're worth the trouble to find...and hear!

Liked the photo of the All-Star Quartet as well, that group had such potential, and never quite lived up to it...but, oh, the talent within!

By Inquirer1 on Wed, December 31, 2003 - 6:10:50

Another great job as usual John. While we were spending Christmas in Florida, my dad went out and bought the "Bad Boy of Gospel Music" book by Calvin at Books-A-Million. It is probably the most interesting book about a gospel singer that I've read.

By Alan Kendall on Thu, January 01, 2004 - 7:22:53

Good to see you're back with another history lesson. Great synopsis of the ups and downs of this unique group.


By Dean Adkins on Thu, January 01, 2004 - 1:12:39

The three originals -- Newton, Butler and Robinson -- appeared at the 1973 NQC and were terrific. Calvin's book is most entertaining. Great to see you back with another great article, John.

By norm graham on Thu, January 01, 2004 - 1:22:51


I've heard precious few recordings of this group, but were familiar with the individuals through the writings of others. As usual, you filled in many gaps in my knowledge.

Never knew Calvin Newton and Paul Downing sang together. To my ear, Paul was one of the underrated basses.

Thanks again.

By Mike Ray on Fri, January 02, 2004 - 11:05:50

Thanks John for this history lesson on the Sons of Song. I had forgotten about them. They truly were a unique sounding group. I also never knew Paul Downing and Calvin Newton sang together. And I agree, Paul was underrated as a bass singer.

By Glenn Camp on Mon, January 05, 2004 - 3:05:00

Another incredible job, John. I always thought I knew a lot of southern gospel history - until I started reading your articles. They are priceless. Please keep it up..

By Brad Harris on Mon, January 05, 2004 - 9:23:26

Excellent article John. Welcome back!

By James Hales on Mon, January 05, 2004 - 9:31:59

John, another great article. BTW, I loved that term Gospel music "mafia".

By Deon Unthank on Sat, January 10, 2004 - 3:39:16

"BTW, I loved that term Gospel music "mafia"."

It's a fitting description, don't you think?

By John Crenshaw on Sat, January 10, 2004 - 5:06:01

Great article. I play some of Calvin's music on my SGM radio station ( ). Homeland, Daywind or somebody needs to re-release the Sons of Song music on CD along with some of the great old SGM groups like has been done for the Cathedrals and much of the Gaither groups. Thanks again for the article, John.

By Tony Partigianoni on Sun, January 11, 2004 - 10:56:11

When and how did Paul Downing die? I know it's been several years ago.

By James Allen on Thu, September 02, 2004 - 9:27:02

I was doing random searches on the internet tonight, and found this website. I am very glad to see that there are so many people that were as touched as I was by the music made by my grandfather and others. However, I have to add one thing to the statement that his passing away was seemingly unnoticed by most in the gospel music industry. At his funeral, the procession was miles long, and there was standing room only at the service. Most of these were people that I had never even seen or met before, but who had been touched by his wonderful voice, and his mastery of the piano.
Thank you for this tribute to his and others music.

By Reagan Rodney (granddaughter of Bob Robinson) on Tue, September 14, 2004 - 9:29:36

I was a dj at a radio station (WAMI) in Opp, Alabam in 1959 and the Sons of Song were featured regularly on a daily show called Quartet Convention. I still remember the only LP we had of the Sons of was pink and semi-transparent. One of the more interesting arrangements of "The Old Gospel Ship" was on that album as I recall. I sure would like to get a copy of that LP.

I also remember that the Sons of Song came thru Opp one time singing for Gubernatorial candidate A. W. Todd.

By Sid Gilchrist on Wed, December 08, 2004 - 3:25:16


By DEAN STEPHENS on Tue, April 19, 2005 - 8:13:18

FYI, there is a two-volume set that has over forty songs recorded by the Sons of Song in the Southern Gospel Legends series. If you have not hear this group, you will be simply amazed. of song&searchtype=RhapArtist;-keywords=sons+of+song

By Tony on Mon, February 16, 2009 - 1:35:43

I recently secured Calvin Newton's phone no. and had a wonderful conversation with him. I was also able to purchase some of the Sons of Song DVD
and CD's. We talked about the late '50's. I was there the night he left the Oakridge Quartet, and also the night of the Sons of Son's first appearance in Atlanta.

By Dr. Melvin L. Payne on Sat, May 16, 2009 - 11:21:02

Another great job as usual John...Thanks John for this history lesson on the Sons of Song. You filled in many gaps in my knowledge.
green landimagiacian

By rao on Thu, March 30, 2017 - 6:22:11

excellent blog, very rich in content and correctly thought out, personally I found

here much interesting and useful.....Well! let know my friend as well.

By visual design services on Thu, March 30, 2017 - 7:25:22

I like all songs.. But 2 are my favorite: 1 is highway to heaven and the other is oh when I meet you..

By winter leather jacket on Wed, May 17, 2017 - 6:50:17


Recent Features

  • Glory To God In The Highest
  • Jesus TOOK the Wheel!
  • Christian Fiction Queen: Chasing Mona Lisa
  • Gordon Mote - Singing with Inspiration
  • The Most Wonderful Time Of The Year
  • The Pruitt Family’s 25 Days of Christmas
  • Let’s Cancel Christmas
  • Ones-to-Watch 2016
  • Living Under the Table
  • Merry Christmas! = God Came Down!
  • Worship and Christmas
  • 2015 Christmas Music Guide
  • The Church Hymnal - “Only Give Me Jesus”
  • 1964: A Year That Forever Changed Gospel Music
  • What I’m Thankful For…....
  • Steve Ladd - In Conversation
  • Meet The Pruitt Family
  • Can I Borrow Your Finger?

  • Recent Comments

  • .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) on: Debra Perry & Jaidyn's Call Announced Departure Of Grant Gibson
  • .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) on: LuLu Roman Releases Christmas Project
  • .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) on: This Week on Gospel Music Today
  • .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) on: King's Heralds - Aug 08
  • .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) on: The Presses Are Rolling

  • » moreCommunity Talk


  • Archives

  • image